Nasal Valve Collapse: Symptoms, Cottle Test and Treatment
Nasal valve collapse means that the side walls of the nose fall inwards when you breathe in, narrowing the airway. It can affect the internal valve in the middle of the nose or the external valve near the nostrils; internal valve problems are more common.1 The diagnosis rests mainly on your history and a physical examination; imaging such as X-rays or CT scans is not considered useful for it.2 Nasal strips and internal dilators can ease symptoms in selected people, but surgery is the primary treatment for significant collapse.2
Valve collapse is often mistaken for a deviated septum. Nasal valve repair, however, is recognised as a procedure distinct from septoplasty (straightening the septum), and septoplasty alone does not correct valve collapse.3 This guide explains the internal and external valves, what the Cottle test shows, how strips and dilators compare with surgery, and what is checked at an examination.
In brief
- A distinct cause of blockage: A US expert consensus statement defines nasal valve compromise as a distinct clinical condition.2
- Diagnosed by examination: History and physical examination are the key tools; imaging has not been found useful.2
- Strips and dilators can help: A systematic review concluded that nasal strips and nasal clips relieve internal valve obstruction.4
- Steroid sprays do not open the valve: Without accompanying rhinitis (inflammation of the nasal lining), nasal steroids are not useful for valve compromise.2
- Marked improvement after surgery has been reported: In a meta-analysis of 16 studies, obstruction scores fell by 43 to 50 points out of 100.5
What is the nasal valve? Internal and external
The nasal valve is the narrowest part of the airway inside the nose, and it largely controls how much air flows through. It is described in two parts:1
- Internal nasal valve: the passage in the middle of the nose, formed by the septum, the upper side cartilages and the front end of the turbinate. This is the more common site of valve problems.
- External nasal valve: the area at the bottom of the nose, near the nostrils. Problems here are rarer and the collapse is easier to see from outside.
Pressure inside the nose drops as you breathe in. If the side walls are not firm enough, this pressure difference pulls them inwards and the airway narrows. That is why breathing can become harder with exertion or when lying down.1 For an overview of other causes of a blocked nose, see our guide to chronic nasal obstruction causes.
Symptoms and causes
With valve collapse, breathing becomes harder through one or both nostrils. Mouth breathing during the day, snoring at night and a feeling of congestion may come with it.1 The main causes are:1
- Previous nose surgery: narrowing of the valve can follow rhinoplasty, although severe collapse is less common.
- Trauma: injury to the bones and tissues of the nose can weaken the support of the side wall.
- Ageing: the tissues that support the valve can lose strength over time.
In cosmetic nose surgery, narrowing the nose or removing a hump without preserving support can make the side walls collapse when you breathe in. That is why breathing is assessed when rhinoplasty is planned. We discuss this further in rhinoplasty and nasal breathing.
The Cottle test and examination
At the examination, the doctor first watches the side walls of the nose as you breathe in. In the Cottle test, the cheek is gently pulled to the side to widen the valve area; if breathing becomes clearly easier, the valve may be contributing to the blockage.1
According to the consensus statement, history and physical examination are the most valuable diagnostic tools for nasal valve compromise. Nasal endoscopy (examining the inside of the nose with a thin camera) and photographs can be useful but are not routinely needed, and radiological studies have not been found useful for evaluating the valve.2 The examination also looks for other contributing causes, such as a deviated septum, enlarged turbinates or inflammation of the lining, because nasal blockage often has more than one cause. We explain that distinction in deviated septum or turbinate hypertrophy.
Nasal strips and dilators
Non-surgical options work by holding the valve area open mechanically. Breathing strips stick to the outside of the nose and lift the skin to open the nostrils. Internal nasal dilators sit inside each nostril and press the cartilage outwards to widen the valve.1
A systematic review of 33 over-the-counter mechanical nasal dilators found 5 studies supporting external nasal strips and 4 supporting nasal clips, and the authors concluded that strips and clips effectively relieve internal nasal valve obstruction.4 The consensus statement likewise notes that mechanical treatments may help selected patients.2
These devices only work while they are in use and do not change the structure of the valve, so they are not equivalent to surgery. They are mainly used to support the diagnosis, to ease symptoms for a time, or for people who do not want or are not suitable for surgery. Decongestant sprays do not correct valve collapse either; the problems they can cause with long-term use are covered in our guide to nasal spray addiction.
| Does your nose close when you breathe in?
Briefly describe your concern, including how long the blockage has been present and when it gets worse. If a photo or document is needed, we will tell you how to share it.
Functional surgery: grafts and other methods
The consensus statement identifies surgery as the primary treatment for nasal valve compromise.2 The American Academy of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) recognises nasal valve repair as a distinct surgical procedure.3 The aim is to support the side wall that collapses on breathing in and to widen the valve area. The main methods described in the literature are:
- Cartilage grafts: tissue from elsewhere in the body is used to support or widen the valve; one of the most common is the alar batten graft placed in the side wall.1 Spreader grafts, placed along either side of the septum to widen the internal valve, have also been described.6
- Suture suspension: stitches lift the valve area upwards and outwards.1
- Implants: some centres place an implant inside the nose to support collapsed cartilage.1
The right method depends on whether the collapse is at the internal or external valve, the state of the cartilages, any previous surgery and your expectations about the shape of the nose. As our treatment pages explain, a weak or narrow valve is often supported with cartilage grafts; for small changes, cartilage may come from inside the nose or from the ear, and for larger changes from the rib. The technique itself is planned at the examination according to the structure of your nose.
The evidence on results is encouraging but limited. In a meta-analysis of 16 studies of functional rhinoplasty, nasal obstruction measured on the 100-point NOSE scale (Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation) fell by 43 to 50 points over the 12 months after surgery; because the studies varied widely, the authors stress that confidence in the results is limited.5 A series of 23 patients treated with combined batten and spreader grafts also reported significant improvement in nasal patency and quality-of-life scores.6
| Option | How it works | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Nasal strip | Lifts the skin from outside to open the nostrils1 | Works only while worn; does not change the structure |
| Internal dilator or clip | Pushes the cartilage outwards from inside the nostril1,4 | Works only while worn; some people find it uncomfortable |
| Steroid nasal spray | Used to reduce inflammation of the lining in rhinitis | Not useful for valve compromise without rhinitis2 |
| Functional surgery (grafts, sutures, implants) | Supports the side wall structurally or widens the valve1,2 | Requires an operation and recovery; the method is chosen for each person |
Is septoplasty alone enough?
A deviated septum and valve collapse can exist in the same person. The AAO-HNS describes nasal valve repair as separate from septoplasty,3 and septoplasty alone does not correct valve collapse. That is why the assessment before septoplasty includes watching how the side walls move as you breathe in. Valve repair does not replace septoplasty; when needed, it complements it.
The AAO-HNS position statement does not recommend requiring septoplasty or turbinate surgery before nasal valve surgery.3 In other words, if the valve is the main cause of the blockage, other operations do not have to be tried first. Which structures need correcting is decided from the examination findings, and the septum, turbinates and valve can be treated in the same operation.
Frequently asked questions
Does nasal valve collapse get better on its own?
Because it is caused by weak support, it usually does not resolve by itself; without reinforcement, the side walls can continue to fall inwards, and the supporting tissues can also weaken with age.1
Does the Cottle test confirm the diagnosis?
Do I need a CT scan?
According to the consensus statement, radiological studies are not useful for evaluating valve compromise.2 A CT scan may be requested if another problem, such as sinus disease, is suspected.
Do nasal strips work?
A systematic review concluded that nasal strips relieve internal valve obstruction.4 The effect lasts only while the strip is worn.
Will a steroid nasal spray help valve collapse?
Without accompanying rhinitis, nasal steroids are not useful for valve compromise.2 If you also have rhinitis, the spray may be planned to treat that.
If I have septoplasty, will my valve problem be fixed too?
Septoplasty alone does not correct valve collapse; nasal valve repair is a separate procedure.3 If you have a valve problem, that repair is planned as well, and both can be done in the same operation if needed.
Will valve surgery change the shape of my nose?
Some methods can slightly change how the nose looks; in a series of 23 patients, 22 reported that the appearance of their nose was unchanged or improved.6 It is worth discussing this for your own nose at the examination.
Could breathing problems after rhinoplasty be valve collapse?
They can be. Narrowing of the valve can follow rhinoplasty.1 An examination is needed to find the cause.
Questions to ask your ENT specialist
- Is my blockage coming from the internal or the external valve?
- Are a deviated septum or enlarged turbinates also contributing?
- Would it help to try a nasal strip or dilator first?
- If I need surgery, where would the cartilage come from?
- Will the operation affect the appearance of my nose?
| Let an examination find the cause of your blocked nose
Briefly describe your concern, including which side is blocked and when it gets worse. If a photo or document is needed, we will tell you how to share it. You can see the sharing options on our Photo and Document Sharing page.
Clinical references
- Cleveland Clinic. Nasal Valve Collapse.
- Rhee JS, et al. Clinical consensus statement: Diagnosis and management of nasal valve compromise. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010;143(1):48-59.
- American Academy of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery. Position Statement: Nasal Valve Repair.
- Kiyohara N, et al. A Comparison of Over-the-Counter Mechanical Nasal Dilators: A Systematic Review. JAMA Facial Plast Surg. 2016;18(5):385-389.
- Floyd EM, et al. Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Studies Evaluating Functional Rhinoplasty Outcomes with the NOSE Score. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017;156(5):809-815.
- Faris C, et al. Functional rhinoplasty with batten and spreader grafts for correction of internal nasal valve incompetence. Rhinology. 2006;44(2):114-117.
This article is general information, not a personal diagnosis or treatment recommendation. Seek prompt medical care for urgent symptoms.

